Ties - Part I, assessment and planning
It takes a village to help a baby with ties
TL/DR
Short, and easy to read book - Fit to Be Tied - a Visual Reference for Parents
Follow Bobby Ghaheri on Instagram or read his blog (see a list of articles from the blog below)
Overview of research on ties (Instagram video)
Follow Tongue Tied Experts on Instagram or YouTube
First - I’ve written a narrative about ties and oral/body tension. If you have a few minutes - bear with me and continue reading. If you’d like to skip the next section and go straight to articles, podcasts, videos, etc (I won’t be offended!) click this link to go to the resources below.
Overview
Ties are tight connective tissues (called a frenulum, or frenum) that can be under the tongue (tongue tie), lips (lip ties), or cheeks (buccal ties). Ties cause oral tension, and make it difficult for a baby to feed effectively (breast and bottle). I think of feeding difficulties as an “early warning system” - if a baby can not use their oral motions properly to nurse or bottle feed effectively, there is a higher chance other issues can occur later in life, including aspects of oral-facial development, which can impact speech, eating solids, airway health and more.
The first step when a baby has feeding difficulties is a full functional evaluation (note - this post is not a substitute for that evaluation!). An IBCLC (International Board Certified Lactation Consultant) or SLP (Speech Language Pathologist) with extensive training in oral/body tension are the best practitioners for this evaluation - which is a thorough assessment of:
Baby’s latch to breast and/or bottle
How the baby processes suckling and swallowing (breast or bottle)
Baby’s oral and body range of motion, muscle tone, symmetry
How this affects your experience - pain, milk intake, challenges with milk supply, how often to pump and bottle feed (and balancing it all!), baby’s comfort during and after feedings, and so much more.
Does my baby have ties?
Babies with ties (or oral/body tension) can have a variety of symptoms - some are more obvious than others!
painful/tight latch causing breast nipple/damage
or the opposite - latch feels light (breast or bottle always falls out out baby’s mouth, milk leaks/spills)
frequent plugged ducts/mastitis (from poor milk “removal”)
endless nursing sessions that don’t satisfy the baby
fatigue or falling asleep while feeding (breast or bottle)
clicking, gulping, sputtering or choking (breast or bottle)
fussiness, “colic”, and reflux-like symptoms (air intake from a poor seal around breast or bottle, see reflux-related research article below)
baby can’t hold pacifier
baby refuses bottles
lip blisters
white tongue (it’s almost never thrush!)
tension and/or asymmetry in body and head posture
asymmetry in head shape (or head molding from birth that never resolves)
open mouth breathing
snoring, poor sleep
and so much more!
Parents often work overtime to keep the baby satisfied, gain weight, ease tummy upsets, or maintain their milk supply and breast health. Sometimes babies are gaining and taking in milk - but there can still be oral dysfunction. For example for a parent has strong milk flow, or a baby taking a fast-flowing bottle nipple - the baby may still easily get milk. Sometimes it seems like all is well at first - but if feeding is less effective, milk supply will often decline - and then feeding issues become worse as baby has to work harder and harder for the milk. The same thing can occur with bottle feeding - the baby may start to get fussier and fussier if they are having trouble coordinating the motions needed for the feeding, and may even start to reject bottles.
A tie is like a resistance band and causes fatigue!
Some babies have a good latch (or bottle feed well) for a few minutes but then start to narrow, chomp, fall asleep, etc. Ties and oral tension are like doing exercise with a resistance band - you start off easily, but then get tired after some repetitions. When baby’s tongues fatigue, they start to use the wrong muscles - and compensate with their lips, cheeks, and jaws. This often causes pain, air intake, lip blisters, fussiness, and more.
Sometimes oral tension is not from ties - but from other issues such as tight/asymmetric muscles or connective tissues from vacuum delivery, an umbilical cord wrapped around baby’s neck, long pushing phases in labor, or long NICU stays or other post-birth interventions. The uterus is a tight place and birth and post-birth interventions can be a bumpy ride! So, it’s very common for babies to start off tight or asymmetric.
In the early weeks all babies need to unwind from pregnancy and birth - I call this process “de-uterizataion”.
There’s a “which came first, the chicken or the egg” scenario: are tight/asymmetric muscles in the body causing tension under and around the tongue, lips and cheeks? Or, are tight connective tissues (ties) under the tongue, lip or cheeks pulling on muscles in the face, neck/shoulders, head, and rest of the body?
Oral issues can also occur from oral-motor dysfunction, an immature nervous system, and more. So, taking all of this together, the topic of oral tension and oral function is very complex. Our goal is to determine if the baby may have ties, tight/asymmetric muscles, just need time, practice, exercises and “unwinding” to feed well, or if there is more going on that requires other referrals. This is where bodywork and oral exercises come in.
What if I suspect my baby has ties or tight oral/body tissues?
When frenulum are truly tight and causing functional issues - that is the definition of a tie. But again, my first recommendations is usually time, practicing feeding skills (breast or bottle), and home-based oral and body exercises (linked just above) to help improve tight/asymmetric muscles and feeding skills. Sometimes professional bodywork is an important addition.
If muscular/body tension, asymmetry, or oral/body function are the root issues - then bodywork and oral exercises should improve feeding and oral/body posture. If there are ties in addition to muscular tension, then relieving that tension and aiding overall oral range of motion is still the preferred first choice - because these actions will “pre-loosen” the baby - aiding in the diagnosis, tie-release procedure, healing/re-learning after the procedure, also familiarize you with your baby’s movements, and how they are changing over time.
For this reason it’s important to not rush to tie release - most babies (and their parents!) need some preparation prior to a release - we call this “optimal timing of release”. This gives you time to prepare the baby - and yourself - for the whole process.
An IBCLC can not “officially” diagnose a tie (we are also not allowed to tell you that you have a broken leg even if a bone is clearly sticking out!). But, a tie-savvy IBCLC has extensive experience in assessing oral/body function, determining the likely cause of your feeding issues, aiding the baby’s pre/post release exercises, and guiding your whole journey.
When it’s clear that a baby needs an evaluation to rule in/out ties, and perhaps have the procedure to release them - I have a very specific list of doctors that I refer to. There are too many doctors dismiss ties, or call them “small” or “mild” (there is no such thing), or say that it’s fine because the baby is gaining (which ignores that they may have oral dysfunction and are only compensating to gain weight). On the opposite end there are too many doctors who will release any frenulum (even ones that may not be ties but just needed time and oral/body exercises to function well). And, especially unfortunately - too many that do a poor procedure. The people on my list are very highly vetted from my and my collegues’ experiences. But, again it is crucial that you have a functional evaluation before jumping to any procedures. This page, and also my Ties, Part II page, discuss why.
But, before you go on to Ties, Part II - here are resources to help you learn more about ties and oral/body tension.
I have broken the info into different categories - support groups, articles, videos, books, podcasts, Instagram pages. Think of this as your “library” - pick your favorite learning style to start and choose a few to start. If you want more, come back. My top choices have *** next to them
Facebook Tongue Tie groups
There are groups for most states/countries too - search for your area and/or join the Tongue Tie Babies Support Group to connect with people all over the world, and help find a specific group near you.
These groups are very informative and supportive - but please remember that ties, or any kind of oral tension/dysfunction, can not be properly evaluated through a picture or video! Only a thorough functional evaluation (see above) can truly determine the source of your issues.
Articles
*** Articles by Bobby Ghaheri (tie specialist in Portland, Oregon) - here are my top hits from his blog, and click the above link for more:
Types of Tongue Ties (anterior to posterior ties)
Why baby’s weight gain is not the only marker of successful feeding
Choosing your providers - does laser vs scissor matter? Quick answer is no! The skill of the provider matters the most. This article also has questions you can ask your provider to vet them.
Why parent’s symptoms are just as important as baby’s symptoms
Why the healthcare system often fails parents when it comes to ties
Why compensations (lip curling, cheek suction, and more) are problematic (even if a baby is gaining weight).
*** How Bodywork and Ties interrelate - “Is Your Baby a Tether-Berg or a Tether-Floe” by Michale Chatham, RN, BSN, IBCLC, OMT makes a fantastic analogy - that the tension from a tie can be like an iceberg (90% under the surface) or like an ice floe (all on the surface). Bodywork helps relieve tension, and it’s wonderful for all babies - but for a “Tetherberg” baby, it’s essential
Very informative and short overview of ties by Dr. Chelsea Pinto DDS
Article by Breastfeeding USA - great overview.
Research by Scott Siegel (Oral and Maxillofacial Physician/Ties specialist in NYC) demonstrating that reflux and ties are related.
Tongue-Ties and Sleep Issues - by Richard Baxter, discusses the relationship between ties and high palates, snoring, sleep apnea and more.
And, another article describing a correlation between ties and a high palate (this one is more focused on lip and buccal (cheek) ties), by Daniel Lopez, DO
As you do research, you will see unfamiliar phrases and acronyms. Robyn Merkel-Walsh, an SLP in Northern NJ, has created a very informative “cheat sheet” with explanations for phrases and other topics relating to ties.
Videos
Tongue Tie Experts YouTube Channel - excellent interviews with Bodyworkers, IBCLCs, Tie-release providers, SLPs and more! Here are my top hits, and go back to the link above to find more:
*** Scott Siegel (Oral and Maxillofacial surgeon) - tie evaluation and procedure
*** Jackie Hines (Physical Therapist/Cranial Sacral Therapist) - bodywork
*** Michelle Ariante and Rebeca Four (IBCLCs) - lactation, infant feeding and ties
Lisa Paladino, CNM, IBCLC (who does the above interviews) also sells a very thorough course called the “Comprehensive Guide to Tongue Tie for Parents”, including 5 video modules, info downloads and more.
Very thorough video series by Richard Baxter (author of “Tongue Tied” book listed below).
The Broken Eating Mechanism - Part I, Part II - videos (part II is an interview with an SLP and ENT) discussing how tongue tie and other oral dysfunctions relate to speech, eating, sleep disorders, ADHD, anxiety, and more.
Airway and TMJ - how open mouth breathing can impact palate, tonsils, airway, jaw, teeth, posture, and more
Research and animation of oral/facial development comparing tied vs non-tied babies through adults.
Books
*** “Tongue Tied” - Richard Baxter, DMD and multi-disciplinary team (IBCLC, SLPs, Chiropractor, OT, Dietitian). An excellent (and easy to read) book covering ties through all stages of life.
*** “Fit to Be Tied - a Visual Reference for Parents” - by Renee Beebe, MeD, IBCLC, Short and thorough book book with many pictures for visual reference.
“SOS 4 TOTs” - by Lawrence Kotlow, DDS - how tongue/lip ties affect breastfeeding, speech, dental development and pediatric health in general.
These books are for adults considering their own oral health and possible ties
“Jaws: The Story of a Hidden Epidemic” - by Sandra Kahn (orthodontist) and Paul R. Ehrlich (evolutionist) - why our jaws and other mouth structures have become more restricted/crowded over time.
“Breathe: The New Science of a Lost Art” by James Nestor - how oral health matters for healthy breathing, and a healthy life.
“Gasp!: Airway Health - the Hidden Path to Wellness” by Michael Gelb and Howard Hinden - how sleep-disordered breathing relates to poor oral health and functional airway.
“Six-Foot Tiger, Three-Foot Cage” - by Felix Liao, DDS - how lifelong issues can arise from issues with mouth structures.
Podcasts (you can also find these on most podcast apps)
*** The Tongue Tie Experts Podcast (same episodes are on the YouTube channel above) - Lisa Palladino, CNM, IBCLC
The Untethered Podcast - Hallie Burkin, MA, CCC-SLP, COM
The Breastfeeding Talk Podcast episode on ties
The Boob Group Podcast episode on ties
The Badass Breastfeeder Podcast - many episodes on ties
Babies in Common Podcast - several episodes on ties
Podcast from the American Academy of Otolaryngology with an interview with Bobby Ghaheri relating to his tongue-tie research studies
Instagram Pages
@drghaheri
@tonguetiebabies
@tonguetieexperts
@teamtonguetie
@brooklynmyo
@lactationsolutionsofprinceton (that’s my page! I follow and repost many pages that relate to ties)